Avoiding the Eighth Deadly Sin: How to Ensure that Project Conclusions are Implemented
The new "Deadly Sin" was brought forward by a Board member responsible for a group of project managers carrying out transformational projects across a large number of European subsidiaries. He explained that there had been a number of situations where a project lead by one of his managers had worked well and delivered a new, improved process at one of the subsidiaries.
There had been a presentation to the SteerCo and with the help of some input from the Board sponsor the SteerCo had agreed to the suggested changes and the high-level implementation plan.
However, six months later it turned out that the issues that the new processes were meant to address (late deliveries, low customer satisfaction, etc) had not improved and that the root cause of this was that the new processes had not been implemented. We had a broad discussion of what the reasons for this were, and agreed that one of the core reasons was that there was seldom any structured follow-up of the agreements that had been made at the end of the design phase of the project.
I believe that this problem should be included in any overview of why projects go wrong . I also have to admit that the main reason that I have not thought about this earlier is that the type of blue-chip consultants where I have worked are usually only involved in the early phases of the projects, and are less concerned with the actual implementation.
This is, of course, one of the main reasons for using internal project teams with end-to-end responsibilities that includes implementation instead of external consultants.
Why are the results of projects not implemented? There are a number of core reasons (some quite valid) for this:
- Very often teams are more optimistic than actually warranted about the real buy-in and acceptance that they have created for their conclusions and recommendations
- Environmental changes may make the agreed changes less attractive than originally believed. An example is if the success of an agreed change to a delivery process is dependent on a new product being launched, but the launch has been delayed
- Priorities within the organization may change. An example could be if the local company has to focus all its free resources on meeting the threat of a new product launch from its main competitor
- The natural inclination of people to give higher priority to the activities that are required for making "today" successful
While issues related to truly getting the required buy-in and acceptance need to be dealt with in earlier stages of the project, the other factors can be successfully dealt with by firstly developing sufficiently detailed implementation plans as part of the overall project deliverables and then putting in place and using a pro-active and structured benefits tracking process.
Such a benefits tracking process should follow-up on the overall implementation plan and key milestones, it should measure the fulfillment of agreed targets, and it should include the opportunity to report back on changes in environmental factors and priorities.
If the benefit tracking process needs to follow-up on a number of projects (as part of an overall program), then the benefits tracking process should also be multi-layered and focused on exceptions where decisions need to be made rather than giving the same level of detail on all projects.
The advantages of such a benefits tracking system are many, and include:
- There is even more pressure on the project to deliver good work and ensure buy-in as they know the quality of their work will be followed up
- Even if buy-in for the conclusions and recommendations coming out of the project is not 100%, it becomes more difficult not to carry out agreed actions if they are being followed up
- Pro-active follow-up will enable a top-down understanding of environmental developments and changes in priorities, and will allow the development of an agreed "Plan-B"
- The fact that implementation is being followed up makes action much more likely as people will feel the pressure of upcoming milestones and deadlines.
No. of Times this article has been viewed : 511
Date Published : Sep 26 2010
Take a FREE Business Profitability Assessment and find out what steps you can take TODAY to grow your business. Join the Business Mastery Insiders Secrets Club and get instant access to the latest business growth strategies,profitability tools, training, and management resources.